Supreme Court to Take Roundup Case

The Supreme Court agreed Friday to hear an appeal from global agrochemical manufacturer Bayer to block thousands of state lawsuits alleging it failed to warn people that its popular weedkiller could cause cancer. The justices will consider whether the Environmental Protection Agency's approval of the Roundup weedkiller without a cancer warning should rule out the state court claims, the AP reports. The Trump administration has weighed in on Bayer's behalf, reversing the Biden administration's position and putting it at odds with some supporters of the Make America Healthy Again agenda who oppose giving the company the legal immunity it seeks.

Some studies associate Roundup's key ingredient, glyphosate, with cancer, though the EPA has said it is not likely to be carcinogenic to humans when used as directed. Bayer disputes the cancer claims but has set aside $16 billion to settle cases. At the same time, it has tried to persuade states to pass laws barring the lawsuits. Georgia and North Dakota have done so. The high court will take up a case from Missouri, in which a jury awarded $1.25 million to a man who developed non-Hodgkin lymphoma after spraying Roundup on a community garden in St. Louis. The Supreme Court in 2022 declined to hear a similar claim from Bayer in a California case that awarded more than $86 million to a couple.

Germany-based Bayer, which acquired Roundup maker Monsanto in 2018, contends the Supreme Court should intervene now because lower courts have issued conflicting rulings. Bayer faces about 181,000 Roundup claims, mostly from residential users. It has stopped using glyphosate in Roundup sold in the US residential lawn and garden market. But glyphosate remains in agricultural products. It's designed to be used with genetically modified seeds, including corn, soybeans, and cotton, that resist the weedkiller's deadly effect. It allows farmers to produce more while conserving the soil by tilling it less. Bayer has said it might have to pull glyphosate from US agricultural markets if the lawsuits persist. It's unclear if the case will be argued in the spring or at the start of the next court term in October.